My Neighbor Kept Hearing a Woman Scream Inside My Empty House

My next-door neighbor stormed over and insisted I do something about the woman screaming inside my house every afternoon. The problem was, I lived alone, and I spent every weekday at my office downtown from 7:40 to 5:30. So the next morning I acted like I was heading to work, slipped back in through the laundry room door, and hid inside my bedroom closet. Almost three and a half hours later, I heard a key turn in my front door. Then footsteps on the stairs, coming toward my bedroom, and a woman’s voice. What happened after that showed me that the life I’d been living outside Columbus, Ohio, for the last twenty-six months was resting on something unthinkable…
My name is Noelle Brandt. I’m 41, and until that Wednesday I was sure that when people died, they stayed gone.
My husband, Jared, was killed, or so I was told, in a chain-reaction wreck on Interstate 71 a little over two years ago.
His pickup went up in flames after the crash. The state identified what was left of him through his dental records, and everyone, from the coroner’s office to our pastor, gently told me not to look.
They handed me his ashes in a cherrywood urn. We had a service at the Methodist church where we got married, and I spent the next twenty-six months learning how to breathe without him.
I lived by myself in our brick house in the suburbs, out the door before eight every morning and home a little before six every night.
At least, I believed I was by myself.
All of that changed the evening my neighbor caught me in the driveway.
“Noelle, you have got to put a stop to this!”
Mrs. Pruett was standing at the edge of our split-rail fence, red in the face, her arms crossed over her cardigan.
“Put a stop to what?”
“The screaming! Four afternoons now, I’ve heard some woman hollering inside your house.”
I just looked at her.
“That can’t be. There’s nobody in there.”
“Yesterday she yelled, ‘Give them back!’ Today something hit a wall so hard my dishes rattled.”
The skin on my arms prickled.
That night I went through every room, every closet, even the crawl space.
Every window was latched. Nothing was gone, as far as I could tell.
But in the kitchen, something stopped me.
Jared’s orange Bengals coffee mug was sitting upside down on the drying rack.
I hadn’t touched it since the funeral. I couldn’t.
I hardly slept.
By morning, I’d made up my mind.
At 7:35, I put on my work clothes, grabbed my bag, and backed out of the driveway like any other day.
A few blocks over, I left the car in the back lot of a Kroger and walked home along the alley behind the houses.
I let myself in through the laundry room, went upstairs without a sound, and tucked myself into the back of my walk-in closet behind Jared’s winter coats, which I still hadn’t given away.
I held my phone in my lap with 911 already typed in.
For hours, nothing.
Then, a little after eleven, I heard the front lock click.
Whoever it was had a key.
Footsteps crossed the living room. The kitchen faucet ran. A glass set down on the counter.
Then boots on the stairs, heading straight for my bedroom.
The bedroom door opened.
Through the slats of the closet door, I could see tan suede boots, dark jeans, and a green leather purse dropped onto my reading chair.
The woman went right to my dresser and started pulling out the folders where Jared kept his papers.
“Where on earth did he stick it?” she muttered.
Then she called someone and put the phone on speaker.
“Okay, I’m in,” she said.
A man answered.
“Did you find the beneficiary form yet?”
My whole body went numb.
I knew that voice.
I had heard it say “I do” in front of two hundred people. I had heard it sing badly in the shower and read our grocery list out loud in the car and say “night, Noey” every night for eleven years.
It was Jared.
“Not yet,” the woman said. “It’s not in the blue folder like you said.”
“Then look in the cedar box. And hurry, Tess. She gets home at six on the dot. She’s a creature of habit.”
That’s the sentence that pushed me out of that closet. Not the shock. Not the grief. The fact that he still knew my schedule down to the minute, and he was using it against me.
I shoved the closet door open so hard it banged against the wall.
The woman spun around and screamed. Not a little gasp. A full scream, the kind Mrs. Pruett had been hearing all week. The phone slid off the dresser and hit the carpet, and I heard Jared say, “Tess? Tess, what happened?” before the line went dead.
She was younger than me, maybe thirty-two, with tired eyes and a chipped manicure. She didn’t look like a criminal. She looked like somebody who hadn’t slept in a month.
“You’re supposed to be at work,” she whispered.
“And he’s supposed to be dead,” I said. “So I guess we’re both surprised.”
I expected her to run. She didn’t. She sat down on the edge of my bed and started shaking.
Her name was Tessa. She lived in a rental outside Lexington, Kentucky. She had met Jared four years ago at a trade show in Louisville, and he’d told her he was divorced. They had a three-year-old boy named Cooper and a baby girl, eleven months old.
Two years ago, she said, he showed up on her porch with burns on one hand and told her his ex-wife’s family was dangerous and they’d have to live quietly for a while. He started going by Wade. He kept the money. He kept the car keys. Lately, he’d started keeping the kids.
“He took them to his cousin’s in Tennessee on Saturday,” she said. “He says I don’t get them back until I find that form. That’s what I was yelling about every day. I’d call him from here and scream at him to give them back.” She wiped her face with the sleeve of her jacket. “I didn’t know anybody could hear me.”
The form was a beneficiary change on a second life insurance policy, one I’d never known existed. One point four million dollars through his old employer. The insurer had been sitting on the claim for two years because the original paperwork naming the beneficiary had never been found. Jared had filled out a new form before the “accident,” naming a little company in Tessa’s name, and then lost track of it in the chaos of disappearing.
If the form surfaced, the money went to Tessa’s company. And Tessa’s company, like everything else in her life, belonged to Jared.
I knew exactly where the cedar box was. It was on the top shelf of the closet I’d just climbed out of. I took it down, opened it, and there it was, folded in thirds under his grandfather’s pocket watch.
Tessa looked at it. Then at me.
“You could burn it,” she said. “Right now. It’d be over.”
“No,” I said. “It’s evidence.”
We called the police together, sitting side by side on my bed, from my phone. Then Tessa did the hardest thing I’ve ever watched another person do. She called Jared back and told him, in a voice as steady as she could make it, that she’d found the form and would meet him at the Cracker Barrel off the interstate in Florence with the paper in her hand, but only if Cooper and the baby were in the car.
They were. Two state troopers and a detective were waiting in the parking lot. Jared was arrested between a rocking chair and a display of peppermint sticks. Tessa had both babies in her arms before he’d finished asking for a lawyer.
I thought that was the end of it. It wasn’t.
Three weeks later, the detective came by my house and sat at my kitchen table, turning his hat in his hands.
“Mrs. Brandt, there’s something else about the man in the truck.”
Jared hadn’t been alone that night on I-71. He’d picked up a hitchhiker at a truck stop near Wilmington, a 58-year-old man named Harold Voss from Indiana. The wreck was real. Jared climbed out of the cab before the fire. Harold didn’t. And Jared, standing on the shoulder of that highway, looked at the flames and saw a way out.
The dental records had come from Jared’s old fraternity brother, a dentist in Dayton, who’d swapped the charts for thirty-five thousand dollars. He’s been arrested too.
Harold’s daughter, Lynette, had been searching for him for twenty-six months. She’d filed missing person reports in three states. She told the detective she still left her porch light on every night.
That night I sat in my living room and looked at the cherrywood urn on the mantel. I had talked to that urn. I’d kissed it on our anniversary. I’d cried myself to sleep on the couch beside it more nights than I want to count.
It had never been my husband. It was somebody’s father.
The following Saturday, I drove four hours to a small town outside Muncie, Indiana, with the urn buckled into the passenger seat. Lynette met me on her porch, under that light. I’d planned a whole speech in the car. I didn’t use any of it. I just handed her the urn, and she held it against her chest and said, “Hi, Daddy. You’re home,” and the two of us stood there on the steps and cried like we’d known each other our whole lives.
When the insurance company finally closed the case, the money went nowhere near Jared. With the help of a lawyer, part of it went to Lynette’s family. Part of it went into a college fund for Cooper and his baby sister, because none of this was their fault.
Jared will be in prison a very long time. I haven’t visited, and I won’t.
As for Mrs. Pruett, I brought her a pecan pie to thank her for not letting it go. She took it, looked at me over her glasses, and said something I still think about.
“I have to tell you, honey. The screaming wasn’t the first thing. I saw him walking down the alley back in August. Same limp, same ball cap. I told myself I was a foolish old woman seeing ghosts.” She patted my hand. “I figured if I told you I’d seen your dead husband, you’d have me put in a home. So I complained about the noise instead and hoped you’d go look.”
I hugged her right there by the fence.
Jared’s Bengals mug is gone now. I dropped it in the trash the night Lynette called to tell me they’d buried her father in the town cemetery, next to her mother, with a proper headstone and his real name on it.
I keep my porch light on these days too. Not because I’m waiting for anybody. Just because I know now how much it means to someone when it stays lit.