I Followed My Husband and Learned Why the Widow Hugged Him

I drove my husband’s forgotten lunch pail to the paper mill, and his foreman told me Alden had been let go back in the spring. “Ma’am, he hasn’t clocked in here in eight months.” Every morning since, Alden had kissed me goodbye before daylight.
That was the first time the story he’d been telling me stopped holding together. I was seventy-two years old, and I was sitting in the mill parking lot with his black lunch pail in my lap, trying to understand where my husband had been going every morning.
Alden had gone to work at the paper mill when he was twenty-four. He’d carried that same lunch pail through forty-four years of marriage. I packed it most mornings, even when he teased me about how much food I put in it.
“Woman, you’re fixing to make me fat,” he’d say when he saw the pound cake.
Pimento cheese on Monday, ham on Tuesday, and a slice of pound cake every day. He’d kiss my forehead at the back door and say, “See you at supper, Suzy.” I sold insurance in Jesup for forty-one years. I knew how a family could get turned upside down by one phone call, and I knew the value of a small kindness.
I remember every widow whose policy I paid out. Six or seven years before this, I’d held Harold Tolar’s widow’s hand while she signed for his check.
I’d done that work for years, but I never expected to be sitting alone in a mill parking lot with a lunch pail and my own private fear.
Last Thursday, Alden left the pail sitting on the counter after his truck pulled away. I didn’t see it until he was gone. He was diabetic, and I couldn’t stand the thought of him going all day on a vending machine, so I fixed my hair and drove it out to the mill.
The office was a little window beside the time clock. A big man in a hard hat came over when I called. His name was Terrell. I’d met him once at a Christmas party, where he’d been polite and Alden had spent half the evening telling him about the mill.
“I’ve got Alden’s lunch,” I said. “He went off without it.”
Terrell looked at the pail for a long moment. Then he took off his hard hat. A man doesn’t do that for ordinary news.
“Ma’am, he hasn’t clocked in here in eight months,” he said. “They let the old crew go in March.”
“That can’t be right.”
“I’m sorry, Miss Susan. I figured he told you.”
He walked me out to my car and held my elbow as if I might fall. I was more embarrassed than I wanted to be. I had brought a lunch to a place where my husband no longer worked.
“You want me to call somebody?” Terrell asked.
“No, thank you, Terrell. I’m fine.”
I wasn’t. I sat there with that lunch pail on my lap. For eight months, Alden had kissed me before daylight and left the house as if he were headed to the mill. Every week, he’d put $300 in the cookie jar for groceries. I spent it at the Piggly Wiggly as usual.
I had a small habit of counting that money before I went shopping. I never thought about where it came from. I should have asked. That afternoon, I kept hearing Terrell say eight months.
That night at supper, I asked Alden how work had been.
“Long,” he said. “That pump on number three busted again. Terrell like to cussed the paint off the wall.”
“Bless his heart,” I said.
He told it well, too. He gave me details about the pump and Terrell’s temper. I passed the butter beans and let him talk. I didn’t want to accuse him without knowing what had happened, but I also didn’t know how to look at him.
I barely slept. In the middle of the night, I got up and took my Medicare card from the junk drawer. I just wanted to hold something with my own name on it. Isn’t that silly? I was seventy-two, and I thought, Lord have mercy, I’m fixing to find out my husband has another woman.
Then I thought maybe I didn’t want to know. I could keep spending the cookie jar money and keep my mouth shut. Nobody got hurt but me. That sounded reasonable in the dark, which tells you how scared I was.
By morning I’d changed my mind. I needed to see where Alden went, even if I was ashamed of following him.
His truck pulled out before daylight. I gave him a minute, then followed.
He didn’t turn toward the mill. He drove north, past field after field of peanuts, and crossed two counties before turning onto a dirt road beside a mailbox with Tolar painted on it.
I knew the name. I had paid Harold Tolar’s life policy to his widow and held her hand while she signed. I pulled off near a pecan grove across the road and watched a little white farmhouse with a green tin roof.
Alden’s yellow work gloves hung on the porch rail. They were the ones I bought him at Tractor Supply. The screen door opened, and a gray-haired woman came out in a pink housecoat. She hugged Alden like she’d been waiting all night for him to get there.
She patted his cheek. He headed toward the barn, whistling.
He hadn’t whistled at home in a year. I sat in the car and cried until the front of my blouse was wet. Then I wiped my face and got out. I walked across the dirt road in my good shoes, past his gloves, and knocked on the screen door with my wedding ring hand.
She came to the door with a dish towel over her shoulder. She looked at me, and her eyes went soft as butter.
“Oh, honey,” she said. “You must be Suzy. He’s told me every single thing about you, except why he asked me not to tell you he’d been let go.”
That was the answer. The woman wasn’t his other woman. She was Harold Tolar’s widow, and Alden had been working for her since the mill let him go.
I gripped the edge of the screen door. For one second I felt foolish for all the hours I’d spent imagining another woman. Then the anger came up. He’d lied to me every morning for eight months.
“He asked you not to tell me?”
“He said he wanted to tell you himself,” she said. “He said he’d find the right time.”
“Did he tell you when that would be?”
She looked down at the dish towel in her hands. “No, honey. He didn’t.”
I wanted her to say more, but I didn’t want to make her responsible for my marriage. She had not made Alden lie. Still, I couldn’t leave with half the truth.
“Why did he come here?”
“He came by after he lost the job and asked whether I needed help around the place. He remembered that Harold had talked about the old barn when you were here with the policy. The gate was sticking, and some boards needed replacing. I had no money to hire a crew, but I could pay him for the work.”
She glanced toward the barn. “He said he didn’t want charity. So I gave him a job.”
The word job hurt more than it should have. He had one. He just hadn’t told me.
“Does he come every day?”
“Most weekdays,” she said. “He fixes things, takes care of the yard, and helps me with the barn. I pay him by the week. He said the money was for your groceries.”
I looked toward the porch rail. His gloves were still there. His morning visit, his work, his whistling. The picture I’d made in my head had been wrong, but the lie was still mine to deal with.
“Would you bring him here?” I asked.
She didn’t ask me to come inside. She turned and called toward the barn.
“Alden, your wife is here.”
I heard a tool drop against wood. Then Alden came around the side of the barn, wiping his hands on his work pants. He was smiling when he first saw the porch. The smile disappeared when he saw me.
“Suzy.”
I was glad to hear my name in his voice, though I was too angry to let that soften me.
“Eight months, Alden?”
He looked at Mrs. Tolar, then back at me. “She told you.”
“She didn’t need to. Terrell told me when I brought your lunch to the mill.”
He rubbed his palms on his pants again. “I was going to tell you.”
“When?”
“I don’t know.”
“Did the mill let you go in March?”
“Yes.”
“Did you come home that day and kiss me goodbye the next morning as if nothing had happened?”
His mouth tightened. He looked down at the dirt. “Yes.”
I felt my face getting hot. I wanted to shout. Instead, I had to ask the question that had kept me awake.
“Are you having an affair with her?”
“No,” he said at once. “No, Suzy. Nothing like that.”
Mrs. Tolar stood still in the doorway, her hand around the dish towel. She looked sad, not offended.
“He comes here to work,” she said. “And to have coffee sometimes. That’s all.”
I believed her. That didn’t make me feel better. It only removed the easiest explanation and left the harder one: Alden had chosen to hide the truth from me because he thought I couldn’t be trusted with it.
“I’d like to see what he’s been doing,” I said.
Mrs. Tolar nodded. “I’ll get my notebook.”
She went into the house and came back with a small notebook. She had written down the days Alden worked and what she paid him. She turned it toward me. The entries went back to spring. The weekly payments were $300.
“I keep track so neither of us has to guess,” she said. “He has been paid for the work.”
I looked at the pages. There was nothing there about a romance, nothing about a secret life. Just the dates he had been there and the money he had earned.
“You gave me this money every week,” I said to Alden.
“I did.”
“And told me you were at the mill.”
“Yes.”
I looked at the notebook again, though I knew what it said. It felt strange to be standing beside a stranger’s barn while she gave me the plain record of my husband’s life.
“Why?” I asked.
He took a breath, then seemed to give up on finding a nicer way to say it. “I was embarrassed.”
“Embarrassed enough to lie every day?”
He pressed his lips together. “When they let the old crew go, I thought I’d get something else right away. I didn’t want you worrying. I kept telling myself I was going to tell you when I had a new job.”
“You could have told me before you had a new job.”
“I know.”
“No, you know now.”
That came out sharper than I meant it to. I was not sorry. I’d spent the night blaming myself for suspecting him, and now I was furious that he’d given me the reason.
He looked at the ground. “I thought you’d look at me like one of your widows.”
“Those women had lost their husbands.”
“I know what you do all day. I didn’t want to be another person you had to feel sorry for.”
It was the cruelest thing he’d said, and he said it because he was ashamed. That explained the words. It didn’t make them fair.
“I never looked at you that way,” I said. “You made the choice for me.”
He glanced at Mrs. Tolar, then back at me. “I didn’t know how to come home and say I wasn’t working at the mill anymore.”
“You knew how to tell me about a pump that never broke.”
His face tightened. “I shouldn’t have said that.”
“No. You shouldn’t have.”
Mrs. Tolar folded her notebook closed. “I told him he ought to tell you,” she said. “I didn’t want to be between a husband and wife. But I should’ve told him he couldn’t ask me to help keep it from you.”
I appreciated that she said it. I also knew that if I had arrived at her door in a worse state, she might have been the first person I blamed. I was grateful she hadn’t tried to calm me with a pretty story.
Alden stepped closer. “Suzy, the money I gave you came from here. I didn’t take it from our savings. I didn’t borrow it. I earned it.”
“I know where it came from now.”
“I wanted you to have the grocery money.”
“And I did. But I thought you were at the mill.”
He rubbed a thumb over a split in one of his work gloves. “I liked giving it to you. It made me feel like I was still doing my part.”
“You were doing your part when you worked here. You were doing your part when you told me the truth, too.”
“I know.” He looked up at me. “I got too far into the lie. Every day made it harder to stop.”
It was an honest answer, though not a good one. I could see the beginning of the deception: a man losing a job and wanting a few days to find his footing. I could see the way each day made the next lie easier. I couldn’t pretend I wasn’t angry that he had let me spend eight months believing him.
“What did you think I’d do if you told me?” I asked.
“I thought you’d worry. I thought you’d ask what we were going to live on. I thought you’d see me as old and useless.”
“You don’t get to decide what I can handle.”
“I know.”
“Stop saying that unless you mean to do something with it.”
His head dipped. “You’re right.”
I looked at Mrs. Tolar’s closed notebook, then at Alden’s gloves on the porch rail. The hurt was mine to carry, but the choice was mine too. I could go back to the car and leave him standing there. I could also ask him to come home and tell me the rest without shaping it to spare his pride.
I was afraid if I gave him that chance, I’d be letting him off easy. Maybe he was right about me. Maybe I had spent so long fixing other people’s problems that I was ready to fix his before he had to face what he’d done.
“I may lose the little trust I have left if I do this,” I said. “But I’m giving you one chance to tell me the whole truth. We go home, and you tell me what happened from the day they let you go. No more pretending.”
Alden nodded. “All right.”
“Don’t nod. Answer me.”
“All right,” he said again. “I’ll tell you.”
I turned to Mrs. Tolar. “Thank you for hiring him. And thank you for showing me the notebook.”
She reached for my hand, but I wasn’t ready to be comforted. She understood and let her hand fall back to the dish towel.
“I’m sorry you found out this way,” she said.
“So am I.”
Alden walked to his truck. I went to mine. Neither of us asked the other to ride together. We drove home separately, and I got there first.
When he came in, he sat down at the kitchen table. He told me how the foreman had gathered the old crew and said the mill was letting them go. Alden had come home angry, and then ashamed of being angry. He’d decided not to tell me until he’d found another job.
He called Mrs. Tolar because he knew I had once helped her with Harold’s policy and had spoken about the farm and its old barn. She needed help, and he needed work. He had thought a few weeks would be enough time to find something else. When it wasn’t, he kept going to her place and kept leaving the grocery money in the cookie jar.
He told me there wasn’t another account or another woman. He’d been paid for his work. When I asked if there was anything else he had hidden, he said no, then waited for me to decide whether I believed him.
“I don’t know yet,” I said. “I know what the notebook says. I know you lied about the mill.”
He lowered his eyes. “I understand.”
“I don’t need you to understand. I need you to stop doing it.”
He nodded, caught himself, and said, “I will.”
I told him I wasn’t leaving him that night. I also told him I wasn’t going to help him keep pretending. If he was working at Mrs. Tolar’s place, then that was where he was going. He could tell me when he left and when he came home. He said he could do that.
The next morning, he stood at the back door with his gloves in his hand. He didn’t kiss me or say he was going to the mill. He waited.
“I’m heading to Mrs. Tolar’s,” he said. “There’s a board on the barn door I need to replace.”
I opened the cabinet and took out the bread. “You’ll need something to eat.”
He looked at me as if he hadn’t expected that. “Yes, please.”
I packed him a sandwich and a slice of pound cake. He put the black lunch pail on the counter while I closed it.
“See you at supper, Suzy,” he said.
I put the lunch pail in his hand, and this time I knew where he was going.