web analytics
Health

My Husband’s Christmas Checks Had a Name He Couldn’t Explain

On Christmas morning, my husband handed every grandchild a $5,000 college check except my granddaughter. “She’s not blood, Bess. She gets a gift card.” My granddaughter smiled like it didn’t hurt, and I knew it did. I didn’t say a word in front of the children.

I married Herb ten years ago, after we had both lost our first spouses. I was Bessie, though he mostly called me Bess, and I had run a beauty shop out of my garage in Norfolk, Nebraska, for forty years. I’d heard plenty of family secrets over a sink full of rinse water. I never expected to have one sitting under my own Christmas tree.

Herb was a good dancer and a bad saver. When we married, he had a paid-off house, a bass boat, and about nine dollars. I had my little house, which I sold, and the life insurance my late husband left me. I put that money into a savings account in my name. The checks were green, with little red cardinals in the corner. I liked the cardinals. They made an ordinary bank envelope feel a little less ordinary.

Two years before that Christmas, I’d had a scare with my heart. I worried about being in the hospital and needing someone to pay a bill or get money for me, so I put Herb on the account as a signer. That meant he could use it if I needed him to. I told him, “Just for emergencies, honey.”

“Whatever you say, Bess,” he said.

I took him at his word. I suppose that’s the part I was nervous to admit later. I trusted him, and I didn’t check the account very often.

My son’s girl, Kassie, was seventeen. Her daddy died when she was nine, and she’d lived with her mama since. She was a senior and wanted to be a nurse. She came every Sunday to do my hair now that my hands shook too much to manage the curlers. She never made a production out of helping. She’d just sit me in the kitchen chair, dampen my hair, and get to work.

The Sunday before Christmas, she rolled my curlers and told me she’d been accepted into the nursing program.

“Grandma, I got into the nursing program,” she said. “I just don’t know how I’ll pay for it yet.”

“We’ll figure it out, sugar,” I told her.

She said she was going to work nights at the truck stop. She’d already asked them. I told her I was proud of her, but I didn’t tell her I’d made up my mind to help after New Year’s. I wanted it to be a surprise. I figured there’d be bills to look at and things to arrange, and I could make sure the money went where it needed to go.

Herb’s three grandchildren came at Christmas and Easter, if there was food. They called me Bessie, never Grandma, and that was all right. I bought them presents and wrapped each one with a bow I curled myself. I was glad to have them in the house, even when the youngest had his face in a phone the whole visit.

Christmas morning, everybody was in our living room in their pajamas. Herb’s daughter, Janice, was there with her husband and their two boys. Herb’s son’s girl was there too, sitting off to one side with her phone. Kassie sat on the floor by the tree in the sweater I knitted her. I had coffee in my hand and was trying to keep the cup warm.

Herb stood up with a stack of envelopes. He had a grin on his face like he’d been waiting for the right time to bring them out.

“Grandpa’s got a little something for college,” he said.

He handed one to each of his three grandchildren. The oldest boy tore his open first. When he saw the check, he called out the amount.

“Five thousand dollars! Grandpa, are you serious?”

Janice squealed and hugged her daddy. Herb puffed up like a rooster. I watched him enjoy being thanked, and for a few seconds I thought he must have put money aside without telling me. I didn’t know how he’d managed that, but I was trying to make the moment fit the man I thought I knew.

Then he reached into his robe pocket and tossed something to Kassie. It was a gas-station gift card, the kind they sell at the register. Twenty-five dollars.

“Here you go, kiddo,” he said.

Kassie looked at the card and then at me.

“Thank you, Grandpa Herb,” she said, polite as church.

My coffee went cold in my hand. I was embarrassed for her, and furious with him, but I didn’t want the children to have to sit through a grown-up fight on Christmas morning.

So I went to the kitchen and asked Herb to come in.

“Why does Kassie get a gift card?” I asked him. I kept my voice low.

“Bess, she’s not blood,” he said. “She gets a gift card.”

“She’s my blood,” I said.

“Her people can handle her college,” he said, reaching for a cinnamon roll.

“Her people is me, Herb.”

He laughed and walked back out to the tree. I stood at the counter and held on with both hands. Through the doorway I could see Kassie folding up wrapping paper so nobody else had to. That’s the kind of girl she is.

I was still trying to decide whether to go back in and say something when I saw the oldest boy’s envelope on the table by the door. It was open, and a green check stuck out. The little red cardinal in the corner caught my eye.

Those weren’t Herb’s checks. He didn’t have five thousand dollars, let alone fifteen. They were my checks, from my account, from the money I’d kept after selling my house and from my first husband’s life insurance. Herb hadn’t asked me. He hadn’t even told me. He’d just decided he could give my money to his own grandchildren.

I thought about yelling. I thought about taking those checks right out of the children’s hands. But they were children, and it was Christmas, and they hadn’t done anything wrong. Kassie was on the floor with that little gift card in her lap, watching me.

Maybe I was making too much of it. Maybe a good wife would let it go. Then I heard Herb say, “Janice, put that in the bank Monday before Grandpa changes his mind.”

Everybody laughed.

I set down my coffee and went back into the living room. I smiled at them, though my face felt tight.

“Before you go to the bank,” I said, “humor an old lady.”

Janice looked at me. “What, Bessie?”

“Would one of you boys read me what’s printed at the top of your check?”

Herb’s face changed. His grin slipped at the corners.

“Bess, come sit down,” he said.

“I’m fine standing,” I said.

The oldest boy shrugged and held his check up to the lamp. Kassie put down the gift card and watched him. He squinted at the top corner, where the name and address go.

“It says Bessie,” he read. “And this address.”

I looked at Herb. “Those checks came out of my account.”

The oldest boy lowered the check. Janice’s smile disappeared, and her husband leaned over to see it for himself. Kassie didn’t move from the floor.

Herb reached toward the boy. “Give it here.”

“Don’t,” I said.

He stopped with his hand halfway out. The whole room got so quiet I could hear the tree lights ticking softly against a branch. I wanted to take the check and make the problem disappear. Instead I stayed where I was.

Janice looked down at the printed name again. “Dad, is that true?”

“Bess put me on the account,” Herb said. “I’m allowed to sign.”

“That’s not what she asked,” Janice’s husband said.

Herb looked at me, not at him. “You told me I could use it.”

“For emergencies,” I said. “I told you that when I added you as a signer.”

He opened his mouth, then shut it. His eyes went to the three envelopes on the table. He still had that cinnamon roll in his hand, and he’d taken a bite out of it.

Janice’s younger boy looked from his check to his mother. “Grandpa said he was giving it to us.”

“I was,” Herb said quickly. “I meant to give you the money.”

“With Bessie’s money?” Janice asked.

He tried to smile. “It’s our household money.”

I felt my cheeks get hot. “It was my account before we married. It’s still in my name.”

“I’m a signer,” he said. “You put me on there.”

“I did. So you could help me if I was in the hospital. I never said you could hand out my savings.”

He looked at Janice as if she might help him. “I thought she’d be glad I was doing something for the kids.”

Janice took the check from her son, careful not to tear it. “You told us you’d saved this.”

“I didn’t say that.”

“You said, ‘Grandpa’s got a little something for college.’ You let us believe it was yours.”

“I was going to put it back,” he said.

That was the first time he’d said anything about putting it back. Nobody had heard him say that before. I hadn’t, and neither had Janice.

“From where?” I asked.

Herb looked at me. “I don’t know yet. I’ll figure it out.”

A small, ugly part of me wanted to say, You always say that. It would’ve been true. He’d had a paid-off house and a boat and not much money saved. But I was standing in front of our family, and I didn’t want to humiliate him just because he’d humiliated me. I still said the part I regretted.

“You’ve had ten years to figure it out.”

He flinched. For a second I felt sorry for him, then I looked at Kassie and remembered the gift card in her lap.

Herb shifted his attention to the children. “Come on. Your grandmother and I will talk about it later.”

Kassie stood up. She kept her hands at her sides. “You gave them college money and gave me a gas card. Was that supposed to be a joke?”

“No,” Herb said. “You know I care about you.”

“Then why did you say I wasn’t blood?”

He glanced at me. “I was trying to be fair to my own grandchildren.”

“You were fair to them,” I said. “You were unfair to her, and you used my money to do it.”

He started to answer, but Janice spoke over him.

“Dad, don’t make this about her. Did you write those checks from Bessie’s account?”

Herb rubbed his thumb along the edge of his robe pocket. “Yes.”

I hated hearing him say it so plainly. It made what he’d done harder to soften. The boys weren’t to blame, and I wanted that clear before anybody walked out carrying a check they thought they were meant to cash.

I looked at the oldest boy. “I don’t blame you for taking the envelope. You thought it was a gift from your grandpa. But I need the checks back while I find out what happened.”

He looked embarrassed. “I didn’t know, Bessie.”

“I know you didn’t, sweetheart.”

His mother nodded at him. “Hand it to her, honey.”

He gave the check back. Janice took the envelope from her other boy, and he handed his over without a fuss. The girl who was Herb’s son’s child stood there holding hers. She looked from the check to Herb.

“Is it really Grandma Bessie’s money?” she asked.

“It is,” I said. “I didn’t know about the checks until this morning.”

She folded her envelope shut and placed it on the table. “Then I don’t want it.”

Herb’s face tightened. “You don’t have to do that.”

“I don’t want something she didn’t agree to,” she said.

Kassie still held the gift card. I turned to her. “You didn’t do anything wrong, sugar. This isn’t yours to fix.”

She looked down at the card. “I know.”

I wanted to hug her, but I didn’t want to turn her into the reason for a family fight. She wasn’t. The reason was right there beside the tree, with his robe pulled closed and a half-eaten cinnamon roll still in his hand.

Herb tried again. “Bess, I thought we were a family. I thought what was yours was ours.”

“I told you whose account it was. I let you sign on it because I thought I could count on you in an emergency.”

“You never said I couldn’t write checks.”

“I never said you could.”

He looked around the room. I could tell he wanted somebody to say I was being too hard on him. Nobody did. Janice’s husband folded his arms. Janice kept all three checks in her hand. The boys had gone quiet, and the girl had moved closer to Kassie.

Herb’s voice got smaller. “I wanted my grandchildren to have help. They may need it.”

“So might Kassie,” I said. “She’s working nights at a truck stop to pay for nursing school.”

“I didn’t know about that.”

“You didn’t ask.”

He looked at Kassie, then at the gift card. For a moment I thought he’d offer her more money. Instead he said, “I thought your mother would handle it.”

“My mother does what she can,” Kassie said. Her voice shook a little, but she didn’t look away. “Grandma helps me because she wants to.”

Herb turned back to me. “I didn’t mean to hurt anybody.”

“Then why did you make sure everybody heard that she wasn’t blood?”

He looked at his hands. “I didn’t think it through.”

That sounded like him. It also sounded like an excuse he expected me to accept because I’d accepted so many little things over the years. I had let him make plans with money he hadn’t saved. I’d let him keep the bills in a drawer and tell me he’d get to them. I had mistaken his easy way of talking for proof that things were fine. I didn’t want to keep doing that.

Janice set the checks down on the coffee table. “Dad, I can’t let the boys take these. I thought this was money you had put away for them.”

“I said I was going to make it right.”

“I’m not asking for a promise,” she said. “I’m asking you not to use Bessie’s money.”

He looked at me. “You want to cancel the checks on Christmas?”

I looked at the children. The oldest boy had gone from excited to ashamed, and I hated that my answer might make him feel responsible. “I want the checks back. They were written without me knowing. The money isn’t yours to give.”

Nobody argued after that. Janice gathered the envelopes. Her husband helped the boys put their coats on. The girl handed her check back to me and said, “I’m sorry, Bessie.”

“You didn’t do anything wrong either,” I said.

When they started for the door, Herb stayed beside the tree. He didn’t follow them. Kassie came over and put the gift card on the table with the returned checks.

“Do you want me to go?” she asked.

“No, sugar. You can stay.”

She hugged me then, and I put my cheek against the top of her head. I was furious, and I was ashamed that Herb had put her in the middle of it. I also knew I couldn’t take back the way he had spoken to her. All I could do was stop him from spending my money and make sure she knew she mattered to me.

Janice lingered by the door with her husband. “I’m sorry, Bessie. I didn’t know.”

“I believe you.”

She looked toward her father. “Dad, you need to sort this out with her.”

Herb’s jaw tightened. “I will.”

Janice didn’t answer him. She left with her family, and the front door closed behind them. The house seemed too big for the three of us still inside it. Kassie sat down by the tree, and I took the envelopes and checks to the kitchen.

Herb followed me in. “You didn’t have to do that in front of everybody.”

“You gave the checks in front of everybody.”

“I was trying to do something good for my grandchildren.”

“You wanted them to think you had saved the money.”

He frowned. “I didn’t say that.”

“You let them think it.”

He leaned on the counter. “Bess, I thought you had plenty in that account.”

“That doesn’t make it yours.”

“I’ve taken care of you.”

“You’ve been my husband. That isn’t the same as owning my savings.”

His face showed anger now, which was easier to look at than his earlier embarrassment. “So what do you want me to do? Apologize?”

I looked at the check envelopes spread on the counter. The cardinals on the checks seemed brighter than they had that morning. “I want you to stop using my account. I want you to tell Janice the truth, and I want you to let me handle my money.”

He stared at the checks. “You’re going to make me look like a thief.”

“You used my checks without asking me.”

He didn’t answer. Kassie came into the kitchen and stood in the doorway. She didn’t need to hear any more. I put the checks in a drawer and closed it.

After Kassie left, Herb and I sat at the kitchen table. He asked me to wait until after the holiday to call the bank. He said the children would be disappointed, and Janice would think badly of him. I told him I understood that they would be disappointed. I also told him I’d be calling as soon as the bank opened.

He said I was making it bigger than it had to be. I told him I wished it had been smaller. Then I went to bed and slept badly.

On Monday, I carried the returned checks to the bank. I had the account information in a folder, along with the old papers from when I sold my house. I don’t usually make a fuss at a counter. That morning, I asked the employee to tell me exactly who was listed on the account and what Herb could do as a signer.

She checked the account and told me it was mine. Herb was listed as an authorized signer. I could remove that access, and I could ask the bank to place stop payments on the checks he had written. The checks had been returned to me, but I wanted to be sure they couldn’t be used if one went missing.

She turned the screen slightly so I could confirm the account. My name was there, just as I had said. I had to swallow before I could speak.

I knew removing him might change my marriage. It would tell him I no longer trusted him with this part of my life. Maybe he was right that I was making it bigger than it had to be. Maybe I had made my money into a wall between us.

Then I remembered Kassie thanking him for a gift card after he’d called her not blood.

“Please remove him as a signer,” I said. “And put a stop payment on those three checks.”

The employee asked me to confirm the checks and the account. I did. She entered the requests, printed the paperwork, and asked me to sign. I signed my name. My hand shook once, and I held the pen tighter.

When I got home, Herb was at the table. I told him I’d removed his access and stopped the checks.

“So that’s it?” he asked.

“That’s what I needed to do.”

“You don’t trust me at all now?”

“I trusted you with my account. You used it without asking.”

He started to say something, then looked down at the table. I didn’t comfort him. I was still hurt, and I wanted him to understand that a promise to pay it back later wouldn’t change what he’d done.

He didn’t leave the house. I didn’t tell him to. But that evening I moved my account papers from the drawer he used to the small locked box in my closet. He saw me carry them past the living room and didn’t ask where I was taking them.

Janice called later. She said she had told the boys the checks were not a gift they could keep. She was angry with Herb for saying he had saved the money, and embarrassed she’d been excited before she knew where it came from.

“I should’ve asked,” she said.

“You had no reason to question him,” I told her. “He made it sound like he was giving it.”

She said Herb had called her and told her I had overreacted. Then he had admitted the money came from my account. Janice said she’d told him he needed to apologize to me and to Kassie, not explain it away.

I was grateful she hadn’t made the boys feel guilty. They hadn’t done anything but open a Christmas present from their grandfather. Later, the oldest boy called to say he was sorry he’d read the check out loud. I told him he had nothing to apologize for. He’d read exactly what was printed on it.

That week, Herb did apologize to Kassie. He did it in the kitchen, with me there. He said he shouldn’t have called her not blood and shouldn’t have handed her a gift card after giving the other grandchildrencollege checks. “I was wrong,” he said. Kassie looked at him for a moment, then nodded. “Thank you for saying that.”

The three checks were stopped, and Herb no longer had access to my account. I told Kassie I was paying for her nursing program, just as I’d planned before Christmas. She squeezed my hand, and I set the green checkbook with the red cardinals beside her acceptance letter.

Back to top button
Close